Bowen Family Systems on Targeting and Scapegoating

Source: Pexels/cottonbrostudio

​​​​​Scapegoating is a sociopsychological phenomenon in which a person or group unjustly shoulders the blame for problems they did not instigate. This defensive mechanism permits individuals or societies to project their issues onto others, thereby diverting attention away from the actual causes of their predicaments. Historically, scapegoating has repeatedly surfaced during periods of crisis, conflict, or societal tension.

Historically, groups like Jews have frequently been cast in the role of scapegoats. This pattern can be traced as far back as medieval Europe when Jews were blamed for various societal ills, including plagues, economic downturns, and political instability. The most tragic manifestation of this was during the Holocaust when Nazi propaganda scapegoated Jews for Germany's post-WWI economic hardships and societal unrest.

In modern times, echoes of this historical pattern are evident. Many critics of Israel's policies towards Palestinians, particularly in the Gaza Strip, have crossed the boundary between legitimate criticism and anti-Semitic rhetoric—blaming Jews as a collective for the actions of the Israeli government. This is an example of scapegoating that shifts blame from the complexities of the conflict and the roles of various actors onto the Jewish people.

From the perspective of Bowen Family Systems, this phenomenon can be viewed as a societal triangle, where tensions between Palestinians and their leadership are projected onto a third party, specifically Jewish people. This process diverts attention from the internal issues faced by the people in Gaza, including governance challenges, economic instability, and human rights concerns.

To break this cycle, fostering open and informed dialogue about conflict is crucial. This involves emphasizing the multifaceted nature of the issue and the responsibility of all parties involved. It also requires challenging anti-group rhetoric whenever it surfaces while acknowledging the legitimate grievances of all people.

The historical targeting of groups can be traced back thousands of years and stems from a combination of religious, social, economic, and political factors. This has manifested in various forms, including religious persecution, economic marginalization, and conspiracy theories. These factors have perpetuated harmful stereotypes and the scapegoating of groups.

Bowen Family Systems Theory provides a framework for understanding how family dynamics and societal systems influence human behavior. This theory suggests that individuals and groups behave in ways that maintain balance and manage anxiety within their respective systems. Applying this theory to the historical targeting of different groups reveals several key dynamics:

1. Differentiation of Self: Individuals with higher levels of differentiation can better separate their feelings from the group's anxieties, enabling them to respond more rationally and empathetically. Throughout history, Jewish communities have often exhibited a high level of differentiation, focusing on education, resilience, and maintaining their traditions. This differentiation has contributed to their ability to endure challenging circumstances.
2. Triangles and Emotional Fusion: Bowen's theory emphasizes the role of triangles in interpersonal relationships. When anxiety arises, individuals may seek to alleviate it by involving a third party, often through blaming or scapegoating. Scapegoated groups have frequently found themselves trapped in such triangles, becoming easy targets for societies seeking to deflect attention from their problems. Recognizing and addressing these triangles can help break the cycle of scapegoating.
3. Multigenerational Transmission Process: This refers to the transmission of emotional patterns and anxieties across generations. Historical traumas and collective memories can influence how individuals and groups perceive themselves and others. Acknowledging the impact of historical trauma on identity can foster resilience and empower future generations to respond differently.

To break free from the cycle of scapegoating and targeting, consider the following steps:

1. Education and Awareness: Promoting education about history, culture, and contributions can dispel stereotypes and challenge misconceptions. This can contribute to dismantling the foundations of scapegoating by fostering understanding and empathy.
2. Coalition Building: Building alliances with diverse communities can foster solidarity and collectively combat discrimination. By working together to address societal issues, people can demonstrate their commitment to justice and dispel the notion that they are responsible for others' problems.
3. Promoting Dialogue and Engagement: Encouraging conversations about historical trauma, resilience, and the impact of scapegoating within communities and with others is crucial. This can help heal wounds and build bridges of understanding.
4. Embracing Differentiation: Nurturing differentiation within communities allows for critical thinking, emotional resilience, and the ability to respond thoughtfully to challenging situations. Embracing diversity of thought and encouraging individuality can help break the patterns of scapegoating.

Therapy Essential Reads

How Does Pronatalism Impact Therapy?

The Common Core of Psychotherapy

By applying the Bowen family systems theory, we gain insight into the dynamics perpetuating scapegoating. Communities can respond differently by fostering education, building alliances, promoting dialogue, and embracing differentiation. By doing so, they can contribute to a more inclusive and compassionate society, where scapegoating hopefully can become a thing of the past.