Why We Crave Unrequited Love: The Allure of the Unavailable

Source: RDNE Stock project/Pexels

Have you ever found yourself inexplicably drawn to someone who seems just out of reach—perhaps after they rejected you or ended your relationship?

It's a frustrating yet common experience: the more they pull away, the more we find ourselves wanting them. Despite the obvious signs that they're not as invested, our mind plays tricks on us, convincing us that there's something special about this person—something worth pursuing.

This dynamic is explored humorously and dramatically in the book and movie He's Just Not That Into You. Despite its widespread popularity, the message often falls on deaf ears. When someone distances themselves, our instinct often isn’t to move on, but to hang on, no matter the cost.

But why do we pine for those who rejected or dished us and who don't return our feelings? What makes us obsessed with people who place us at the bottom of their priority list?

The Scarcity Effect: When Less Means More

One reason we may find ourselves infatuated with someone who’s not into us is rooted in what psychologists and philosophers call the "scarcity effect." This principle suggests that we tend to place higher value on things that are scarce or hard to obtain. Think of a rare collectible or a limited-edition item—its rarity increases its perceived worth. The same principle applies to relationships.

When a person is less available—whether emotionally, physically, or both—we unconsciously start to value them more. Their attention becomes something we strive for, precisely because it’s not readily given. This can lead us into a vicious cycle where their unavailability feeds our desire, making it even harder to let go.

Evolutionary Misfires: Why We Chase the Wrong People

From an evolutionary standpoint, it might seem puzzling that we would become fixated on someone who doesn’t reciprocate our feelings. After all, the ultimate goal of attraction should be to find a compatible partner with whom we can form a bond and, historically speaking, ensure the continuation of our genes. So, why are we drawn to people who are not interested?

One theory suggests that this behavior is an evolutionary misfire—a byproduct of traits that were beneficial in other contexts. For early humans, being part of a social group was essential for survival. Social rejection could mean being cut off from the group, which was a serious threat at a time when isolation could lead to death. As a result, humans evolved a strong aversion to rejection, which manifests today as intense emotional pain when faced with romantic rejection.

In modern society, this aversion can go awry. The emotional distress caused by rejection might prompt us to try even harder to win over the person who’s not interested in a misguided attempt to avoid that pain. This can lead to a fixation on someone who doesn’t return our feelings, driven by a deep-seated fear of social exclusion.

Cultural Narratives: The Power of the Love Story

Culture also plays a significant role in shaping our reactions to romantic rejection. From childhood, we are bombarded with stories that glorify unrequited love and the pursuit of the unattainable. Whether it’s in movies, books, or even music, there’s a pervasive narrative that suggests persistence in the face of rejection is not only noble but often rewarded.

This cultural script teaches us to view love as a challenge, something that must be fought for, even if the odds are against us. Unfortunately, this can reinforce the idea that if we just try hard enough, we can change someone’s mind and win their affection. The reality, however, is that this mindset can trap us in a cycle of unreciprocated love, where we waste time and emotional energy on people who simply aren’t interested.

Relationships Essential Reads

The Importance of Interpersonal Acceptance

Why Do You Love Me? The Quest for Certainty in Relationships

The Social Stigma of Being Single

Social expectations further complicate our reactions to romantic rejection. Society often equates being in a relationship with stability, success, and happiness. When we’re in a relationship, we’re seen as part of a unit, invited to social events together, and regarded as having achieved a significant life milestone.

Conversely, when a relationship ends, it’s seen as newsworthy, especially within our social circles. The end of a relationship can lead to a loss of social status and a change in how we’re perceived by others.

Being single—especially after a breakup—almost inevitably comes with a stigma. Society tends to view single people, particularly those who have been recently rejected, with a certain level of pity or even suspicion.

Social pressures to be an "item," along with a desire to preserve our social identity, can make us cling to relationships that aren’t good for us or chase after people who aren’t interested, simply to avoid the negative judgment that comes with being alone.

Breaking Free and Reclaiming Your Self-Worth

So, how do you break free from the cycle of chasing people who don’t want you? The first step is to redefine your self-worth, separating it from your relationship status. It’s crucial to understand that your value doesn’t diminish just because someone else fails to see it.

Equally important: You are more than your romantic relationships. Your identity isn’t determined by someone else’s interest in you, nor by your relationship status—it’s something you define for yourself.

By recognizing the factors that trigger your destructive behavioral patterns and excessive reliance on external validation, and consciously choosing to redefine your identity, you can begin to reclaim your "self." Remember, the most important relationship you have is the one with yourself—invest in it wisely.