Return to Office, Return to Sexual Harassment?

Source: Yan Krukau/Pexels

As organizations push for a return-to-office (RTO) environment, they face numerous challenges, from logistical concerns to employee resistance. However, one significant issue often overlooked is the potential increase in sexual harassment incidents associated with in-person work. Advocates for RTO need to seriously consider this reality, as current measures from companies, government agencies, and nonprofits appear insufficient to address this critical problem.

Office Harassment vs. Remote Harassment

The evidence linking in-person work environments with higher instances of sexual harassment is compelling. A 19th News/SurveyMonkey poll revealed that employees working in person are more than twice as likely to experience sexual harassment compared to those working remotely. Specifically, 12% of women working in person reported harassment, in contrast to only 5% of remote workers. These statistics underscore the protective barrier that remote work can offer, particularly for women and marginalized groups who are disproportionately affected by workplace harassment.

The poll further highlights disparities across various demographics. Nonbinary workers, for instance, reported a significant decrease in harassment incidents during remote work periods, with 20% experiencing harassment in the past three years, compared to 30% pre-pandemic. For workers under the age of 35, 8% of remote workers reported harassment, versus 14% of those working in person. These figures suggest that remote work environments provide a degree of protection that in-person work cannot match.

Sexual harassment in the workplace often stems from power imbalances, where those in higher positions leverage their authority to exploit subordinates. In an office setting, these dynamics are more pronounced due to frequent, unsupervised interactions. Remote work disrupts these power dynamics by reducing opportunities for in-person coercion and creating a digital trail for communications, which can serve as evidence in harassment cases. However, returning to the office reintroduces these vulnerabilities.

Case Study of Office Harassment: Tata Consultancy Services

We also have clear case studies reflecting the more than doubling of sexual harassment associated with the transition from remote work to in-office work. For instance, after Tata Consultancy Services (TCS) announced its full-time in-office RTO in 2023, sexual harassment cases rose from 49 to 110 within a year.

Yet while TCS Chairman N. Chandrasekaran acknowledged a rise in reported harassment cases, he dismissed remote work as a viable solution, stating, "I don't think we can go to remote working to solve this problem." He emphasized the need for robust in-office policies rather than relying on remote work as a preventive measure, saying he believes that education is the key to reducing harassment incidents by creating a healthy working atmosphere and culture. According to Chandrasekaran, the solution lies in investing in people and building a strong institutional framework rather than relying on remote work as a primary preventive measure.

However, it’s not like TCS, which has over 600,000 employees, lacks education on sexual harassment. Clearly, the transition from remote work to full-time RTO made a drastic difference, more than doubling sexual harassment cases—in line with the 19th News/SurveyMonkey poll.

Government agencies and nonprofits also lag in providing necessary protections against workplace harassment. Data shows that women file about 80% of sexual harassment cases, with a noticeable spike following the #MeToo movement and a slight decrease during the pandemic. However, as RTO policies gain traction, the potential for these numbers to rise again is significant. The absence of updated guidelines and stringent enforcement mechanisms exacerbates the risk.

Solving Office Harassment

Addressing sexual harassment in the context of RTO requires a multifaceted approach. Organizations must develop robust systems for reporting and addressing harassment, both online and offline. This includes incorporating reporting features into remote work tools and ensuring transparency in handling complaints. Regular training on recognizing and preventing harassment should be mandatory for all employees, with a focus on creating a safe and inclusive workplace culture.

Policies must be updated to reflect the realities of hybrid work environments. This includes clear guidelines on acceptable behavior and the consequences of harassment, regardless of whether it occurs in person or online. Providing support for victims of harassment, such as counseling and legal assistance, is crucial. Employers should create safe channels for reporting without fear of retaliation. Regulatory bodies need to enforce stricter guidelines and penalties for organizations that fail to protect their employees from harassment. This includes conducting regular audits and ensuring compliance with anti-harassment laws.

Sexual Abuse Essential Reads

Helping Practitioners Respond to Sibling Sexual Behavior

No More 'Quiet on Set'

As the debate over RTO continues, it is imperative to recognize and address the associated risks of increased sexual harassment. Companies, government agencies, and nonprofits must not only advocate for a return to the office but also implement comprehensive measures to ensure a safe and respectful work environment. By failing to do so, they risk perpetuating a cycle of abuse that disproportionately affects the most vulnerable employees. The path forward requires a commitment to safety, accountability, and the well-being of all workers, regardless of where they choose to perform their duties. And if companies, government agencies, and nonprofits can’t demonstrate that they can effectively lower sexual harassment cases in the office, then perhaps it’s time to seriously reconsider the value of in-office work and support remote work.

A version of this post also appears on disasteravoidanceexperts.com.