What Is Stonewalling and Why Does It Damage Relationships?

Source: Alex Green / Pexels

Imagine you're in the middle of a heated conversation with your partner. You're expressing your frustrations, hoping for a response, a sign that they understand or care about what you're saying. But instead, they go quiet. Their eyes glaze over, arms crossed, as they stare past you like you're not even there.

No matter how hard you try to reach them, it's like talking to a wall. The room fills with tension as your words fall flat, leaving you feeling unheard, dismissed, and completely alone. This isn't the first time, and you know it won't be the last.

This scenario, where one partner emotionally shuts down, is all too familiar for many couples and is known as stonewalling. Though often unintentional, this silent response can devastate a relationship, slowly eroding trust and connection.

What is stonewalling?

Stonewalling occurs when one partner emotionally withdraws from an argument or conversation, refusing to engage or respond. It’s not just silence — it’s a complete shutdown of communication. Whether they are staring blankly, avoiding eye contact, or even physically leaving the room, the person stonewalling essentially becomes unreachable. The partner on the receiving end often feels ignored, dismissed, and powerless to continue the conversation.

While stonewalling might seem like a way to avoid conflict, it’s often a defense mechanism. For some, it stems from past trauma or the fear of escalating a situation they can’t control. Others use it as a means to protect themselves from feeling overwhelmed or attacked. Though it may feel like a protective measure, this behavior only deepens the divide between partners.

Stonewalling often becomes a habit in relationships, especially when difficult emotions are involved. Instead of dealing with frustration, anger, or fear, one partner withdraws entirely, creating an emotional barrier. Unfortunately, this lack of communication only intensifies the issue, leaving both partners feeling disconnected and misunderstood.

The emotional toll of stonewalling

Although stonewalling may be a way to avoid conflict, its emotional toll can devastate both partners. For the person being stonewalled, it creates a sense of isolation and rejection.

Imagine trying to connect with someone you love, only to be met with silence or avoidance. Over time, this emotional wall leads to feelings of frustration, abandonment, and even resentment as the ignored partner begins to feel unheard, dismissed, and undervalued.

However, the impact of stonewalling doesn’t stop there. The person doing the stonewalling isn’t immune to the emotional damage either. While they may be trying to avoid discomfort, they often end up feeling emotionally drained or disconnected from their partner. Avoiding conflict may provide temporary relief, but it ultimately builds tension and pushes the relationship toward a breaking point.

In the long run, stonewalling erodes trust and intimacy. When communication breaks down, so does the ability to resolve conflicts, leading to unresolved issues piling up over time. This emotional distance can create a cycle of negativity that, if not addressed, can lead to long-term dissatisfaction, bitterness, or even the end of the relationship. Both partners lose out as the emotional connection that once formed the foundation of their relationship crumbles under the weight of silence and avoidance.

Proper communication is critical to breaking the cycle

Breaking the destructive cycle of stonewalling requires intentional, open communication. While stonewalling may seem like an easy way to avoid conflict, the long-term damage it causes far outweighs any temporary relief.

The first step in overcoming it is recognizing when it’s happening. Both partners need to acknowledge the behavior and its impact on the relationship.

Relationships Essential Reads

The Most Important Quality a Romantic Partner Should Have

The Secret Superpower of Positive Memories

For the partner who tends to stonewall, learning to stay engaged in complex or difficult conversations is vital. This may involve taking a brief timeout to cool off rather than shutting down completely. During these breaks, it’s important to focus on calming techniques, like deep breathing, to regain emotional control and avoid falling into the same patterns. Once calm, re-engaging with the conversation and expressing emotions openly helps maintain connection, even in challenging discussions.

On the other hand, the partner experiencing stonewalling should approach these situations with patience. While the silence can feel unbearable, pushing too hard for immediate engagement can backfire. Instead, creating a safe space for communication where both partners feel heard is essential. Encouraging open dialogue without placing blame allows for more constructive conversations and less emotional shutdown.

Sometimes, professional help through therapy or counseling is needed to break deep-rooted patterns. A therapist can provide tools to improve emotional regulation, encourage vulnerability, and teach effective communication techniques. With these strategies, couples can break free from the cycle of stonewalling and begin to rebuild trust, emotional connection, and a healthier way of navigating conflicts.

Though stonewalling can seem like a relationship-ending behavior, it doesn’t have to be. With effort and dedication, couples can rebuild their emotional connection and create a foundation of trust that strengthens their relationship for the long term.

The key is for both partners to commit to honest conversations, even when it's uncomfortable. With patience, empathy, and, in some cases, professional guidance, couples can learn to navigate conflicts in healthier ways. It’s not about avoiding disagreements but rather finding constructive ways to handle them.

Stonewalling may build walls, but with effort and open communication, couples can tear them down and rebuild stronger, healthier relationships.

To find a therapist, visit the Psychology Today Therapy Directory.