Thin Privilege and the Thin Ideal

Source: Photo by Marco Bianchetti on Unsplash

Thin privilege, deeply woven into the fabric of Western society, protects certain individuals from the discrimination faced by those in larger bodies. This privilege manifests as societal advantages bestowed upon individuals whose bodies align with accepted standards. Recognizing this privilege becomes a crucial first step in dismantling the harmful norms perpetuated by diet culture. The significance of thin privilege becomes even more apparent when we consider the harmful measures people take to attain or maintain it and the psychological and physical toll it exacts.

The "Thin Ideal"

Body image experts use the term "thin ideal" to describe a narrow standard of beauty that is widely promoted. Clinical psychologist Niva Piran suggests that "embodying this ideal" more precisely captures the act of conforming to the "thin ideal," as this standard encompasses numerous privileges linked to factors such as weight, body type, age, race, ethnicity, gender identity, and social status ^{1, 2}. This ideal is pervasive and disseminated by cultural institutions such as mass media, beauty, and diet industries. While beauty standards can vary across cultures and individuals, the "thin ideal," referring to the cultural preference for a slender or lean body type, remains dominant.

Unattainable beauty standards, including the "thin ideal," lead to pervasive body dissatisfaction and body comparison, setting the stage for developing an obsession with procuring the body that one cannot have without doing unnatural things to achieve it ³.

Impact on Mental Health and Society

The pursuit of thinness not only reinforces weight stigma but also perpetuates the power of the "thin ideal" as the favored body type. This involves various practices like restricting food intake, purging, over-exercising, and resorting to surgical interventions to conform to societal beauty standards ⁴.

Engaging in weight loss to seek refuge in thin privilege can lead to the development of disordered eating patterns and, in severe cases, life-threatening eating disorders. The relentless pressure to adhere to the thin ideal, fueled by societal expectations and privileges, further complicates this struggle.

Moreover, weight stigma infiltrates everyday experiences, turning basic activities into privileges. Fitting into a seat on a plane, at a restaurant, or on an amusement park ride should not be a privilege exclusive to certain body sizes. Enjoying a dessert or a salad should not invite assumptions about one's lifestyle or goals. Shopping for clothes should be an accessible experience for everyone, irrespective of their body size ⁵.

The Role of the Beauty Industry

The beauty industry perpetuates and capitalizes on the "thin ideal." Registered Dietitian Dalia Kinsey highlights in her 2022 book Decolonizing Wellness that beauty standards are intentionally designed to create a sense of inadequacy, thereby driving consumerism (Kinsey, 2022). The industry establishes these standards while profiting from selling products people believe will bring them confidence, satisfaction, and happiness.

These beauty trends are often impossible or difficult for many people to achieve. For instance, the trend of having large buttocks and a tiny waist, popularized by celebrities, may be attainable for some due to genetics. In contrast, others might resort to surgery or extreme diet and exercise regimens. Similarly, increases in breast size, often considered desirable in Western culture, can be influenced by factors such as hormones, pregnancy, and weight fluctuations, making it challenging for many to achieve these standards naturally.

This beauty standard, rooted in colonialism and racism, idealizes European features and imposes unrealistic beauty expectations on individuals. By understanding these dynamics, we can begin to dismantle the harmful norms perpetuated by the beauty industry and work towards a more inclusive and realistic standard of beauty.

Finding Compassion and Dismantling Harmful Norms

Individuals struggling with body image must find a space of compassion for themselves. How could they not feel ashamed of their bodies or food choices when diet culture's job is to create a feeling of inadequacy? The diet culture rollercoaster, which instills in individuals the belief that their bodies must change to be considered acceptable and attractive, can only be confronted when blame is removed from themselves and those around them. Everyone has been affected by diet culture's toxic messages; everyone has been victimized.

Body Image Essential Reads

Body Neutrality Isn't New or Unique From Positive Body Image

Improving Body Image Among People With a Visible Difference

Setting Intentions for Authentic Well-Being: A Path Toward Change

Challenging thin privilege necessitates intentional actions that prioritize genuine well-being:

• Cultivate Self-Compassion. Extend kindness to oneself, recognizing the importance of self-love and acceptance.
• Reject Body Bashing. Refrain from engaging in negative self-talk or perpetuating harmful language about others based on their bodies.
• Boycott Harmful Industries. Choose not to support products or industries contributing to weight stigma, redirecting energy toward spaces and activities promoting diversity and inclusivity.
• Listen to Your Body. Grant permission to listen to your body's needs and treat it respectfully, nurturing a healthier relationship with yourself.

By understanding, challenging, and setting intentions to prioritize authentic well-being, individuals contribute to a collective shift toward empathy, societal construct challenge, and a redefined ideal, ultimately fostering a more compassionate and inclusive world.

Conclusion

The interplay between thin privilege and societal beauty standards is a complex web influenced by cultural, historical, and economic factors. Addressing this issue requires a holistic approach that includes education, support, and a commitment to changing societal attitudes. By challenging the thin ideal and promoting body diversity, we can work toward a society in which everyone is valued for who they are, not just how they look. Recognizing the harmful effects of thin privilege and diet culture is essential for fostering a healthier relationship with body image and food for all.