Skip to main content

Verified by Psychology Today

Anxiety

Eyelid Flutter May Indicate Deception

Detecting when someone is not being truthful through nonverbal cues.

Key points

  • Eyelid flutter is the rapid, involuntary movement of the eyelids that occurs when we are feeling anxious.
  • However, eyelid flutter alone may not be accurate in determining whether someone is being deceptive.
  • Eyelid flutter should always be considered with other accompanying nonverbal cues
Shinny Diamond/Pexels
Source: Shinny Diamond/Pexels

The eyes are often referred to as the windows to the soul. Eyes convey various emotions, from joy and love to fear and sadness. But sometimes, our eyes can betray us, especially when we are trying to hide something. One common phenomenon that can give away our true feelings is eyelid flutter.

Eyelid flutter is the rapid, involuntary movement of the eyelids that occurs when we are feeling anxious, nervous, or stressed. However, eyelid flutter is particularly relevant when it comes to deception, as it can be a sign that someone is lying or trying to hide something.

One theory posits that eyelid flutter is related to the body's fight-or-flight response. When we perceive a threat, our bodies prepare for action by releasing hormones like cortisol and adrenaline. These hormones can cause a range of physical responses, including the fluttering of the eyelids. Another theory is that eyelid flutter is related to the body's attempt to regulate emotional arousal. When we are feeling stressed or anxious, our emotions can become overwhelming. By fluttering the eyelids, the body may be attempting to regulate this emotional arousal and bring it back down to a manageable level.

In some cases, eyelid flutter can be subtle and difficult to detect. However, in other cases, it can be quite obvious. For example, if someone is being interrogated by the police and their eyelids are fluttering rapidly, it could be a sign that they're feeling anxious or nervous about the questions being asked.

If you are trying to detect deception in someone else, it is important to look for behavior patterns rather than relying on a single nonverbal cue. For example, if someone avoids eye contact, fidgets, and their eyelids flutter, it could be a sign that they are not telling the truth. However, if someone's eyelids are fluttering, but they maintain eye contact and seem otherwise calm, it may be a sign that they are simply feeling general anxiety unrelated to the topic of discussion.

Some people may be better at hiding their emotions than others. For example, people who are skilled at deception may be able to mask their eyelid flutter by consciously controlling their movements. Additionally, people who have a medical condition that causes involuntary movements, such as Tourette syndrome, may experience eyelid flutter even when they are not feeling stressed or anxious.

In conclusion, eyelid flutter alone is not enough to determine whether someone is lying, and it should always be considered in the context of other verbal and nonverbal cues. Some people may experience eyelid fluttering as a natural response to stress or anxiety, even if they are telling the truth. However, when combined with other signs of deception, such as avoiding eye contact or fidgeting, eyelid flutter can indicate that someone is not telling the truth. Observing eyelid flutter is not a foolproof method for determining whether someone is lying and should be used with caution.

References

Schafer, J. & Navarro, J. (2023), Advanced interviewing techniques: Proven strategies for law enforcement, military, and security personnel. Springfield, IL: Charles C. Thomas Publisher.

Givens, D. B. (1998). Center for Nonverbal Studies. Retrieved June 14, 2023, from http://center-for-nonverbal-studies.org/htdocs/6101.html

advertisement
More from Jack Schafer Ph.D.
More from Psychology Today